A new look at African aid
So, as I’ve mentioned, I’m now enamored with TEDTalks.
During my subway ride home from work, I watched one that presented a different view to African aid.
I was immediately intrigued when the speaker brought up the issue of western media constantly portraying Africa as a placed filled with despair,hopelessness, and civil wars…
He said:“The media is telling the truth about Africa and nothing about the truth”
So I’ve decided to transcribe this speech and put it here on my blog for people to read!
I took a 3hour nap today after work, so since I’m awake, I figured I’ll start typing now! But then I reached one page of text for just the first 5 minutes (and I skipped his introductory greetings) and I’ve decided to just link to the video/audio on the TED website.
I mean, they’re free to watch and download, so why not?!
plus… who would read 3 pages of text, when they could watch a 15min video instead?
anyways,
since I did write up the beginning bits, here’s a snippet:
you can read this and if you’re interested in knowing more, you can then watch the video!
..or, you could compare my text to the video and then tell me what I typed wrongly… (oh, that’d be great fun! …please don’t do that. )
Andrew Mwenda: Let’s Take a New Look at African Aid
“…I want to say that there are two things that we need to connect: How the media covers Africa in the west, and the consequences of that. By displaying despair, helplessness and hopelessness, the media is telling the truth about Africa and nothing about the truth. However, the media is not telling us the whole truth, because despair, civil war, hunger and famine, although they’re part of our African reality, they’re not the only African reality and secondly they’re the smallest reality.
Africa has 53 nations, we have civil war only in 6 countries. Which means the media are covering only 6 countries. Africa has immense opportunities that never navigate through the web of despair and helplessness that the western media largely presents to its audience. The effect of that presentation is it appeals to sympathy, it appeals to pity, it appeals to something called charity. And as a consequence, the western view of Africa’s economic dilemma is framed wrongly.
The wrong framing is a product of thinking that Africa is a place of despair. ‘What should be do with it? We should give food to the hungry, we should deliver medicines to those who are ill, we should send peace-keeping troops to serve those who are facing civil war.’ And in the process Africa has been stripped of self initiative.
I want to say that it is important to recognize that Africa has fundamental weaknesses. But equally it has opportunity and lots of potential. We need to reframe the challenge that is facing Africa, from a challenge of despair, which is called Poverty Reduction, to a challenge of hope. We frame it as a challenge of hope, which is Wealth Creation. The challenge facing all those who are interested in Africa is not a challenge of reducing poverty, it should be a challenge of creating wealth.
Once we change those two things – if you say the Africans are poor and they need poverty reduction, you have the international (?) of good intentions moving on to the continent with what? Medicines for the poor, food and relief for those who are hungry, and peace-keepers for those who are facing civil war. And in the process none of these things are really productive, because you are treating the symptoms, not the causes of Africa’s fundamental problems. Sending somebody to school and giving them medicines, ladies and gentlemen, does not create wealth for them. Wealth is a function of income and income comes from you finding a profitable trading opportunity or a well-paying job. Now, once we begin to talk about wealth creation in Africa, our second challenge is: who are the wealth creating agents in a society?
They are entrepreneurs.”
//
I had a tough time trying to find a place to stop that quote! …there’s so much more in the video!
…if it’s not obvious yet… I highly recommend!
that said,
I might as well just embed the video here! ![]()
